Supplying water to millions is not simply an engineering and logistical challenge. As David Soll shows in his finely observed history of the nation's largest municipal water system, the task of providing water to New Yorkers transformed the natural and built environment of the city, its suburbs, and distant rural watersheds. Almost as soon as New York City completed its first municipal water system in 1842, it began to expand the network, eventually reaching far into the Catskill Mountains, more than one hundred miles from the city. Empire of Water explores the history of New York City's water system from the late nineteenth century to the early twenty-first century, focusing on the geographical, environmental, and political repercussions of the city's search for more water. Soll vividly recounts the profound environmental implications for both city and countryside. Some of the region's most prominent landmarks, such as the High Bridge across the Harlem River, Central Park's Great Lawn, and the Ashokan Reservoir in Ulster County, have their origins in the city's water system. By tracing the evolution of the city's water conservation efforts and watershed management regime, Soll reveals the tremendous shifts in environmental practices and consciousness that occurred during the twentieth century. Few episodes better capture the long-standing upstate-downstate divide in New York than the story of how mountain water came to flow from spigots in Brooklyn and Manhattan.Soll concludes by focusing on the landmark watershed protection agreement signed in 1997 between the city, watershed residents, environmental organizations, and the state and federal governments. After decades of rancor between the city and Catskill residents, the two sides set aside their differences to forge a new model of environmental stewardship. His account of this unlikely environmental success story offers a behind the scenes perspective on the nation's most ambitious and wide-ranging watershed protection program.
Informations légales : prix de location à la page 0,7500€. Cette information est donnée uniquement à titre indicatif conformément à la législation en vigueur.
Extrait
EmpîreofWater
EmpîreofWater
AnEnvîronmentaandPoîtîcaHîstoryo te New York Cîty Water Suppy
s
DAV ï D S O L L
C O R N E L L U N ï V E R S ï T Y P R E S S ItHaca&London
LîbraryoCongressCataogîng-în-PubîcatîonDataSo, Davîd, 1971– Empîre o water: an envîronmenta and poîtîca îstory o te New York Cîty water suppy / Davîd So. p. cm. ïncudes bîbîograpîca reerences and îndex. ïSBN 978-0-8014-4990-1 (cot: ak. paper) 1. Water-suppy—Envîronmenta aspects—New York (State)—New York— Hîstory. 2. Water-suppy—Poîtîca aspects—New York (State)—New York—Hîstory. 3. Watersed management—New York (State)—New York—Hîstory. 4. Water-suppy engîneerîng—New York (State)—New York—Hîstory. ï. Tîte.
TD225.N5S65 2013 363.6’1097471—dc23
2012033792
CorneUnîversîtyPressstrîvestouseenvîronmentayresponsîbesuppîersandmaterîastote uest extent possîbe în te pubîsîng o îts books. Suc materîas încude vegetabe-based, ow-VOC înks and acîd-ree papers tat are recyced, totay corîne-ree, or party composed o nonwood ibers. or urter înormatîon, vîsît our websîte at www.cornepress.corne.edu. Cot prîntîng 10 9 8 7 6 5 4 3 2 1
Contents
Preace
vîî
ïNTRODUCTïONEvoutîon o a Water System he 1 CHAPTER ONE rom Croton to Catskî11 CHAPTER TWO Up Country37 CHAPTER THREEDeays, and te Deaware Drougt, 68 CHAPTER OURto te Supreme Court Back 97 CHAPTER ïVE he Water System and te Urban Crîsîs125 CHAPTER SïXRîse o Watersed Management he 148 CHAPTER SEVENte Watersed Agreement ïmpementîng 177 EPïLOGUE Puttîng Poîtîcs în ïts Pace206
Notes215 Bîbîograpy251 ïndex275
v
Preface
îe ï was wrîtîng tîs book, severa peope înquîred about my motîvatîons W or exporîng te îstory o New York Cîty’s water suppy. ï never man-aged to answer te questîon to my compete satîsactîon, nor, ï îmagîne, to teîrs. Noneteess, ï am certaîn about one tîng: uncoverîng te întrîcacîes o govern-ment—îts many movîng parts, dîverse personaîtîes, and dueîng înterests—made tîs an especîay ascînatîng topîc to researc. Oneoteirstdocumentstatïcameacrossînmyresearcwasasongbyengîneers o te Board o Water Suppy, te entîty te cîty estabîsed to construct a new water system în te eary twentîet century. ï soon reaîzed tat tese songs (ît turned out tat tere were dozens o tem) were învauabe sources because tey were wrîtten by and or board empoyees and as suc ofered unîque însîgts înto teîr vaues and desîres. Government was not sîmpy a bunc o aceess bu-reaucrats; ît was aso engîneers toîîng în te Catskî Mountaîns wo onged or “Broadway wît a îts sîgts.” hrougout tîs book, ï requenty reer to te “cîty” or to varîous government agencîes. Noneteess, government îs not monoîtîc, and ï ave trîed to îgîgt te issures tat dîvîde most pubîc bodîes. ï aso ocused on partîcuar îndîvîdu-as wo payed an outsîze roe în sapîng pubîc decîsîons. hîs îs a story o aws, courts, and egîsatures, but ît îs aso a story o îndîvîduas, pubîc and prîvate, wo caenged government to act în te pubîc înterest. Manypeopeentaandînmyefortstotracetejourneysoteîndîvîduasand governments wo înluenced te deveopment o te cîty’s water system. My irst debt îs to te wrîters wo came beore me. here are severa u-engt works on New York Cîty’s water suppy; în addîtîon, many autors ave devoted portîons o books to te cîty’s water network. Dîane Gausa’sLîquîd Assets, andWater-WorksbookcedroduypenanoBeKîvbya,arPoaînGnddedîvorp,bauteauî bot a detaîed summary o te cîty’s water suppy îstory and împortant actua
vîî
vîîî
Preface
detaîs. Many scoars cannot avaî temseves o suc compreensîve overvîews o teîr topîc. Sortyaterembarkîngonmyresearc,ïencounteredasîgnîicantstumbîngbock—because o post-9/11 securîty concerns, ï was not permîtted to use te arcîves o te cîty’s Department o Envîronmenta Protectîon, te prîmary mu-nîcîpa reposîtory o înormatîon on te water network. At te tîme, ï worrîed tat te absence o suc sources woud make ît dîIcut to te te envîronmenta îstory o te water system în rîc detaî. ortunatey, tese concerns proved un-ounded, în arge part due to te abundance o materîas stored în varîous arcîves and îbrarîes. ïapprecîatetesupportandguîdanceoteNewYorkStateArcîves,wereï served as a Larry J. Hackman eow în 2008. James ots and îs staf eped me ocate useu materîas. heîr dedîcatîon to preservîng state records îs a mode o pubîc servîce. ï woud aso îke to tank James Stîmpert and staf members în specîa coectîons at te Eîsenower Lîbrary at Jons Hopkîns Unîversîty, were ï conducted researc în te Abe Woman Papers. he papers are a prîceess store-ouse o înormatîon on water suppy deveopment and sanîtary engîneerîng în te Unîted States. hey provîded a ascînatîng beînd-te-scenes perspectîve on te cîty’s water suppy decîsîons în te 1950s. ï am aso grateu to te Rockeeer Arcîve Center or îts support. heîbrarîesandarcîvesoteCatskîMountaînregîonwereîndîspensabe.heîr newspaper cîppîng ies, tourîsm brocures, and oter materîas greaty en-rîced my knowedge and ave (opeuy) enîvened tîs book. he records o commîssîon earîngs or reservoîr damage cases maîntaîned by Uster County (te Asokan Reservoîr Arcîves) and Hartwîck Coege (te Board o Water Suppy Transcrîpts) are a îstorîan’s deîgt, provîdîng înormatîon on many as-pects o te waterworks expansîon experîence. Syvîa Rozee, town cerk o Oîve, generousy gave me access to te town’s rîc coectîon o documents reated to te constructîon o te Asokan Reservoîr. hanks aso to Edyte Ann Quînn at Hartwîck Coege, wo took an înterest în my project and generousy sared materîas se coected rom Catskî pubîcatîons. hebook’sinatwocaptersdraweavîyonpersonaîntervîews.VîrgînîaSceer and Nancy Burnett deserve enormous credît or avîng te oresîgt and dedîcatîon to record întervîews wît most o te key igures în te 1997 Watersed Memorandum o Agreement negotîatîons. hese întervîews, apty tîtedBeHînd tHe Scenes, greaty enrîced my understandîng o tîs crîtîca perîod în te cîty’s water suppy îstory. hey aso enabed me to conduct more rewardîng întervîews wît severa o tese same îndîvîduas. MyunderstandîngodeveopmentssîncetesîgnîngoteWatersedMem-orandum o Agreement (1997–present) was decîsîvey saped by te extensîve
Preface
îx
întervîews ï conducted wît pubîc empoyees, îndîvîduas empoyed by nongov-ernmenta organîzatîons actîve în New York Cîty water suppy îssues, and actîvîsts. A compete îst o întervîewees appears în te bîbîograpy. Warren Lîebod o te New York Cîty Department o Envîronmenta Protectîon and Tara Coîns o te Watersed Agrîcutura Councî were partîcuary generous wît teîr tîme. ïwasortunatetoaveteopportunîtytoworkwîtMîcaeMcGandyandSara Grossman at Corne Unîversîty Press. Mîcae’s consummate proessîon-aîsm and expert guîdance were te perect it or a irst-tîme autor. ï aso ap-precîate te epu eedback o Martîn Meosî and an anonymous revîewer on an earîer drat o tîs book. ïwaspartîcuaryortunatetoavemanyscoarstoconsutasïresearcedandwrote tîs book. Davîd Stradîng took an aspîrîng envîronmenta îstorîan under îs wîng and ofered exceent guîdance. Hîs wrîtîngs on te connectîons between New York Cîty’s water system and Catskî resîdents were an înspîratîon. ï greaty apprecîate te tîme and înteîgence e contrîbuted to tîs book. Brîan Donaue ofered a vîgorous bend o scoarsîp and actîvîsm. Hîs support, edîtorîa sug-gestîons, and wîde range o contacts greaty împroved tîs book. Jane Kamensky’s keen sense o narratîve and advîce on a wîde range o persona and proessîona topîcs were an învauabe resource. AnAndrewW.MeonPostdoctoraeowsîpînEnvîronmentaStudîesat Laayette Coege provîded te tîme and resources to revîse te manuscrîpt and conduct addîtîona researc. he oundatîon as contrîbuted enormousy to my deveopment and tat o many young scoars trougout te country. ï aso greaty apprecîate te Meon oundatîon’s inancîa support or tîs book. he eowsîp enabed me to take up resîdence on te banks o te Deaware Rîver wîe ï revîsed te manuscrîpt. or tat and many oter reasons, Laayette was te perect pace to tînk about my researc în te arger context o envîronmenta studîes. Dru Germanoskî, wo ed te coege’s envîronmenta înîtîatîve, was a consîstent source o encouragement. hanks aso to two o my bîggest support-ers at Laayette, D. C. Jackson and Eîsabet Rosen. Your bend o crîtîcîsm and encouragement was te perect recîpe. rîendsandamîyavebeenacrîtîcasourceosupportoverteyears.HowardHacker, Pau Skeît, and Jef God provîded deîgtu îkîng respîtes în a pace ar rom New York Cîty. Martîna and Bernd Leger are wonderu rîends wo un-aîîngy supported me în my quest, even toug ît meant eavîng Massacusetts. Wanda eck and Aan and Loîs Paestîne provîded comortabe omes away rom ome on researc trîps to te New York Cîty area. hey may not ave aways been înterested în te detaîs, but te kîndness o my moter, Susan So, and sîsters, Lîsa and Nancy So, eped sustaîn me. Atoug my ater passed away beore ï began tîs project, îs anaytîca mînd-set and respect or ard work and scoary