WG LB8 Comment DB - James Gilb, Decline Letter and 37 RC's by Part of No Vote by Comment Type

Standards Working Group IEEE 802.15 Wireless Personal Area Networks™ Homepage at http://ieee802.org/15 Dr. Robert F. Heile Chair, IEEE 802.15 Working Group on Wireless Personal Area Networks 11 Louis Road Monday, 26 March 2001 Attleboro, MA 02703 Phone: 508-222-1393 Mobile: 781-929-4832 James P. K. Gilb Fax: 508-222-0515 Mobilian Corporation email: bheile@ieee.org 11031 Via Frontera, Suite C, Pager: 800-759-8888 PIN 1109355 San Diego, CA 92127 USA Subject: IEEE P802.15.1 Letter Ballot #8 Comment Resolution Disposition, as of 15Mar01 Dear Mr. Gilb, Thank you for participating in the Letter Ballot #8 that was held from 9Feb01 to 11Mar01. As you learned this WG letter balloted motion passed with 46/4/1 (P802-15/D0.8.0): • There were 74 Voting members. 51 submitted their vote. • The return ratio is 51/74 = 69 % (50 % is required) and the abstention rate was less than 30% of those voting. The ballot is valid. 23 failed to vote. • Motion passed with 46/4/1 or 92 %. During the recent Session #11/Hilton Head the WG LB8 Ballot Review Committee (BRC) was able to review and respond to all 377 comments. The committee has dispostioned the LB8 comments as follows: Comment Status/Response Status WG You Notes Accepted/Closed (AC): 183 74 Please review –01/117r8 to review the committees responses to your comments: LB8 Comment Resolution DB Accepted/Open (AO): 135 26 Accepted/Unsatisfied (AU): 8 2 Rejected/Closed (RC): 51 37 Please see ...