Vport comment bucket v2

Vport ad hoc D1.0 Vport related comment resolutionJanuary 2008Joseph Maggiolino BroadcomAnoop Vetteth Cisco SystemsKeith Hopwood PhihongBill Delveaux Cisco SystemsKest Gue ?Chad Jones Cisco SystemsKirk Hayden Akros SiliconChristian Beia STLarry Shorthill NXPChristophe Gouwy AMI SemiconductorMartin Patoka Texas InstrumentsClay Stanford Linear TechnologyMatthew Landry Silicon LabsDavid Law 3COMPeter Johnson SIFOSEran Bello MicrosemiRamesh Sastry Cisco SystemsFred Schindler Cisco SystemsFred SchindlerRandy Rannow Tyco ElectronicsGeoff Thompson Nortel NetworksRiccardo Russo ST MicroelectronicsGeoff Thompson Nortel NetworksRick Frosch PhihongCisco Systems Gianluca Sanita Nokia Siemens NNetworksTamir Reshef MicrosemiHugh Barrass Cisco SystemsYair Darshan MicrosemiJohn Jetzt AvayaYasuki Kawatsu Hitachi Cable3 ad hocs with an average attendance of 16 people since the last IEEE meeting. 1Vport ad hoc IEEE 802.3at Task Force, January 2008, Portland, Oregon, v1Agenda• Principles based comment resolution• Comment Clusters• Recommendations for the Vport-comment bucket.2Vport ad hoc IEEE 802.3at Task Force, January 2008, Portland, OregonPrinciples to use• Develop some principles to use to guide the ad hoc during comment resolution.Use concise textFocus on what operation you want doneCover only compliance (i.e., avoid discussing noncompliance devices)Do not repeat requirementsChange as little as possible when improving textTry to ...