P1394.3 Comment resolution

P1394.3 Ballot Response Actions Table (BRAT) 20APR03 Resolved technical issues ID Balloter Type Page Line Clause Comment / Remedy Resolution 9 Gene Milligan T 3 6 2.1 Regarding normative references, a normative citing is made of IEEE P1394.1 in the Rejected; the citation of P1394.1 in the scope but it is not listed in the normative references. Scope does not constitute a normative reference. P1394.1 has been added to the bibliography. 10 Peter Johansson T* 3 19 2.2 A note should be added to instruct the IEEE editor to update the reference to the Accepted CSR architecture to cite IEEE Std 1212-2001 if it has been approved by the time of publication for P1394.3. 11 Gene Milligan T 3 25 2.3 The footnote seems to be a carry over from when 1394a was in development. In Accepted; the reference to draft standard addition I thought 1212 was a completed standard with some revision work P1394a has been deleted. underway and I think in ballot. Make it less temporal. 14 Gene Milligan T 5 2 - 4 3 IEEE Std 100-1992 should be listed in the normative references. Accepted; the reference has been updated to IEEE Std 100-2000. 20 Peter Johansson T 6 20 - 21 3.1.2.11 The definition of 'logical unit' seems to imply that devices compliant with P1394.3 Rejected. The working group developed the may not implement more than one logical unit. I do not think that was the intent of draft from the perspective of a single logical the working group. unit. The BRC finds little or no ...