IEEE P802.3ae D4.3 comment responses

P802.3ae Draft 4.3 CommentsCl SC P L Cl SC P L00 52 481 12 # 71 00 52.9.10.2 479 42 # 15Thaler, Pat Agilent Technologies Dawe, Piers AgilentComment Type E Comment Status A Comment Type E Comment Status RThis is a resubmission and update of a comment I made on D4.2 which was overlooked. Ambiguous, as discussed on the reflector. Also I thought we had scrubbed this use of "peak" per a comment last time.Why are Figure 53-12 and Figure 52-11 so different when they seem to be showing the SuggestedRemedysame thing? Also, Figure 53-12 seems to accomplish its purpose in black and white while Replace "For this test, these two components are defined by peak values that include all Figure 52-11 is using color. The existing 802.3 is black and white so we shouldn't add the but 0.1% for VECP and all but 1% for jitter of their histograms."expense of color to the printing unless it is necessary for clarity of the standard.with"For this test, VECP is defined by the 99.9th percentile of the histogram of the lower half of Figure 52-3 also uses color.the signal and the 0.1th percentile of the histogram of the upper half of the signal, and jitter SuggestedRemedy is defined by the 1st and 99th percentiles of the jitter histogram."Make Figures 52-11 and 53-12 the same unless there is a reason for the difference. Make Figures 52-3 and 52-11 black and white. Or may get a better alternative from Tom.Response Response Status Response Response StatusC CACCEPT IN PRINCIPLE. No ...