D1.0 Proposed Comment Responses by ID

Draft 1.0 Comments IEEE P802.3ba D1.0 40Gb/s and 100Gb/s Ethernet comments Task force ReviewCl 82 SC 82.2.8 P 125 L 25 # Cl 82 SC 82.2.18.2 P 134 L 41 #1 4Seung-Hwan, Kim ETRI Seung-Hwan, Kim ETRIComment Type E Comment Status D Comment Type T Comment Status DSpelling: Should be change 'de-skew' to 'deskew' for consistency. Should be change 'per 31.25' to 'per 31.25 us'.SuggestedRemedy SuggestedRemedyProposed Response Proposed ResponseResponse Status W Response Status WPROPOSED ACCEPT. PROPOSED ACCEPT.Cl 82 SC 82.2.4.4 P 122 L 725 # 2 Cl 82 SC 82.2.17.3 P 137 L 30 # 5Seung-Hwan, Kim ETRI Seung-Hwan, Kim ETRIComment Type T Comment Status D Comment Type T Comment Status D amsmAt Data Block Formats and Control Block Formats : Should be change 'am_cnt = 2 *' to 'am_cnt = 4 *'.The slash('/') is used to seperate and represent two 4 bytes transfer in 10GBase-R,SuggestedRemedybut in 40G/100GBase-R there is no need slash('/') between 8 bytes.SuggestedRemedyProposed ResponseResponse Status WPROPOSED REJECT.Proposed ResponseResponse Status W PROPOSED ACCEPT. If I understand the comment correctly, the am_cnt = 2 * is from the VALID_AM to 2_GOOD state transition. This should be 2, only two good markers in a row gets in you lock.Also covered by #202Cl 82 SC 82.2.17.3 P 137 L 33 # 6Cl 82 SC 82.2.17.2.2 P 131 L 18 # 3Seung-Hwan, Kim ETRISeung-Hwan, Kim ETRIComment Type T Comment Status D amsmComment Type T Comment Status DShould be change '2_GOOD' to ...