Comments as received against Draft 2.3 (sorted by comment ID)

IEEE P802.3ap/D2.3 Backplane Ethernet CommentsCl 45 SC 45.2.7.7 P 45 L 25 # Cl 45 SC 45.2.1.7.4 P 26 L 7 #1 4Marris, Arthur Cadence John, Dallesasse Emcore CorporationComment Type E Comment Status X Comment Type E Comment Status Xreference to Clause 28 is wrong During the IEEE 802.3ae meetings, after a (very) lengthy debate on whether to refer to the type of WDM used in 10GBASE-LX4 as ""WWDM"" or ""CWDM"", it was the concensus of SuggestedRemedythe group to refer to it as ""LX4-WDM"". After this debate, it was discovered that all Change 'See 28.2.12' to 'See 28.2.1.2'references to ""WWDM"" or ""CWDM"" had been previously removed from the document, so the concensus was not captured.Proposed ResponseResponse Status OSuggestedRemedyChange all instances of ""WWDW"" to ""LX4-WDM"" (multiple instances).Cl 45 SC 45.2.7.8 P 46 L 14 # 2Proposed ResponseResponse Status OMarris, Arthur CadenceComment Type T Comment Status XBit 7.22.14 in Table 45-122 AN Next Page register should be reserved.SuggestedRemedyChange bit 7.22.14 to be Reserved Value always 0, writes ignored ROProposed ResponseResponse Status OCl 45 SC 45.2.7.1 P 42 L 22 # 3Marris, Arthur CadenceComment Type T Comment Status XThe text ""A device that supports multiple port types may implement both Clause 22 control register operation and Clause 45 control register operation. Some control functions have been duplicated in both definitions. The register bits to control these functions ...